Craigslist has been good to us in the past. We have sold a car, a couch, 2 strollers, and a camera; we've bought a stroller and an arm chair. Each time the sales were easy and we got exactly what we asked for. Not so much the case this last time....
For Christmas this year, Jeremy and I wanted to buy each other a new kitchen table and chairs because the set we inherited was falling apart. After looking around, we knew we couldn't afford a new set so we decided to peruse our faithful Craigslist. We started looking around the end of September because we knew it may take a while to find one that fit our style AND budget. Around the beginning of October, we found one we both liked and set up a time to go see it.
We arrive at this house and the smell is kind of odd. We thought it was what the woman was cooking for dinner. We really liked the set but I was a little apprehensive. But looking at someone's stuff inside their home is ALWAYS awkward. You can't REALLY talk about how you feel about it with your spouse when the owner is standing right there with you. The price was too good to pass up and the man was willing to deliver it to our house (which we really needed).
So we get home and the chair cushions reek. The smoke smell (which we didn't smell before because of her cooking) was so overwhelming that I wouldn't let Jeremy bring them in the townhouse. We stored them in the garage and I was afraid that we had made a huge mistake. I immediately got online and started to research how to get the smoke smell out of upholestry. For the next 2 weeks, we tried everything: baking soda, Febreeze, fresh air, vinegar, Resolve. Finally we had resigned to the fact that we may just have to reupholster the seats so Jeremy disassemble the chairs. We then hand-washed the foam in the bathtub and air them out one last time. Finally that did the trick...we did go buy new fabric though.
We think we are finally in the home stretch now and all we have to do is cover the foam. Jeremy gets out his staple gun and it's not powerful enough to get the staples through. So we borrow one from one of his coworkers...same deal. We wait another week to borrow my dad's...we leave RM without it. Finally we just go buy an electric stapler. Day 1, chair 1 it works great...day 2...doesn't work. I take the gun back and travel to another store to get a better one. Finally 4 weeks after the fact, the chairs are reupholstered and we can finally use our new table. :)
The new chair..with fresh fabric

The whole set

Now decorated for fall

Lessons learned: 1) Really inspected something before you buy it on Craigslist. 2) Walk out of the ear range of the owner before buying something so you can discuss it with your spouse. 3) Smoking is not only bad for your health but also your furniture and budget.